The mayoral contest officially kicked off today with Projet MontrÃ©al taking a strong lead, winning the idiotically-named ‘poster war’ thanks primarily to the fact the party is fielding 103 candidates and an immense volunteer effort. Aside from Projet’s street sign ubiquity, MÃ©lanie Joly may have come in second place (who’s counting?) with her unconventional Super Woman pose and dark background posters.
And in response to a week of outright hostility from nearly all quarters of our city, the Premiere, Benevolent Queen Pauline Marois, announced a MÃ©tro extension. As the CBC puts it, “Montrealâ€™s Metro system is about to get its biggest and most expensive upgrade since the Laval extension.”
In fact, the PQ has announced that they’ve set aside $38.8 million for a planning office with a two year mandate. Whether the PQ lasts that long is another issue.
So don’t get your hopes up – this isn’t a ‘shovel-in-hand’ announcement of the immediate construction of MÃ©tro tunnels. It’s more an announcement of intent to eventually do something.
When it comes to the MÃ©tro, that’s pretty much all we’ve gotten for years anyways. The Charest government made a similar announcement back in 2009 though nothing came of it, and the idea to extend the Blue Line further east dates back to the mid-1980s when the line was first developed. Of note, Charest’s 2009 plan called for closing the Orange Line loop, as well as extensions in both directions of the Yellow Line, in addition to the Blue Line extension, as you can see in the above image. Today’s announcement mentioned that a Yellow Line extension would be contemplated once the Blue Line project is completed.
Why not do both?
Why not do the 2009 plan?
Wouldn’t we save money in the long run if we streamline one big MÃ©tro expansion, rather than small, piecemeal extensions? It would certainly streamline bidding processes and purchasing, no?
The Blue Line’s proposed eastern extension to Anjou (specifically, to an intermodal terminus at the Galleries d’Anjou suburban shopping complex) will undoubtedly alleviate congestion on the Metropolitan Expressway and extend a convenient and efficient mass transit system into a broad medium density residential area. There’s no question about whether the extension is the right way to go, but we need to be vigilant regarding the estimated cost.
The PQ is projecting a $250 to $300 million cost per kilometre and a total extended length of six kilometres (about the distance from University to the Olympic Stadium along Sherbrooke) with five stations. On the outside that’s a $1.8 billion extension to serve a combined population of about 120,000 Montrealers living in the boroughs of Saint-Leonard and Anjou, one hell of an investment in a relatively small number of citizens.
The cost to extend the Orange Line to Laval by three stations cost about half that amount per kilometre, and that project was announced in the late 1990s but only completed in 2007. As you might expect, post-industrial QuÃ©bec takes a lot longer to get anything done.
So don’t expect this Blue Line extension any time soon; those making the announcement today were indicating ‘the beginning of the 2020s’ for ‘full operations’.
Christ; I’ll be old by then.
I’ll say it one more time – we built 26 stations between 1962 and 1967 across three lines and it cost just under $1.5 billion (or 213.7 million in 1966 dollars).
Granted I’m obviously not an economist, but I would like to know why the cost of construction has increased so much in the past decade in particular. You’d figure we’d be getting some kind of rebate in Post Charb Commish Quebec, but this is as expensive as ever.
And we’re not exactly reinventing the wheel either – so how the hell did it suddenly become so expensive to build basic mass transit systems in our city?
There’s another issue we should consider when thinking about the Blue Line and any potential future extensions. It has the lowest ridership of all four lines and the trains are shorter by three cars (you’ll notice that the platforms at Blue Line stations have barricades at either end as the stations were designed to operate ‘full’ nine-car trains). I think this is as a consequence of the line not directly connecting with the city centre.
As long as we’re re-hashing old ideas, why not take a closer look at the original design of Edouard-Montpetit station, which was intended to act as a transfer point between the Blue Line and the commuter rail line passing fifty meters under the MÃ©tro in the Mount Royal Tunnel (as you can see in the station’s original design plan above). The tunnel is now owned and operated by the Agence MÃ©tropolitain de Transport and is in need of upgrading to support new dual-power locomotives inasmuch as some kind of emergency exit at some point in between the tunnel entrances. I would argue strongly in favour of developing a connection between the MÃ©tro and the Mount Royal Tunnel as a means to transfer passengers on the Blue Line to Gare Centrale. This would not only require high-speed, high-capacity elevators (as they have at some Parisian MÃ©tro stations), but the potential construction of a short ‘by-pass’ tunnel deep underground. A difficult job no doubt, but far from impossible.
The benefit is that the Blue Line becomes a lot more useful with this upgrade. I’d even argue prioritizing this element of the original design before any eastern extension. If this connection were made, transferring at Edouard-Montpetit would give Blue Line passengers access to the Orange and Green lines via the Gare Centrale and Place Ville-Marie portion of the Underground City. For the hundreds of thousands of people living along the line’s route, Downtown Montreal suddenly becomes much, much closer – about five minutes from UniversitÃ© de MontrÃ©al to the heart of the financial district.
Such a development could lead to increased land values of properties within proximity of the Blue Line, not to mention give the Blue Line’s extension a more practical raison-d’etre. Call me a cynic, but I smell subtle vote-buying.
Don’t get me wrong – expanding eastwards is a good if very costly idea, and I’d like to know why this is taking so long and costing so much.
But if we’re going to extend the Blue Line’s reach, why not also expand its capacity and increase its utility as well?
I have a feeling realizing the original plan would have the effect of increasing ridership on the Blue Line to such an extent that the STM upgrades to nine-car trains on the line, thus giving the line the ability to truly operate at full capacity.
In any event, I should close with a thought.
There was once a time in which elected officials had to deliver on promises made, otherwise they’d lose the public’s confidence and the right to govern.
This is not the case today. The people are so incredibly disengaged and cynical we don’t expect anything from our supposed leaders at all. We carry on despite them. Sometimes they do something good, most of the time they’re an annoyance, occasionally they’re discovered to be outright criminals.
I don’t know what was so different about life in this city back in the 1960s and 1970s that made the people here demand action and quick results for their political support. I don’t know what lit a fire under people’s asses to get shit done. I know many people suggest Expo and Olympics being the sole motivating factors, but surely this can’t be the case. The people wanted action and their will was respected. We elected, and kept electing, a visionary mayor, who paid us back by giving us a truly global city to live, love and play in.
Today we get flashy press conferences that ultimately only promise more study and preparation for some interminable project whose only purpose seems to be to sap whatever confidence the people have in their elected officials.
I suppose my question is why the PQ isn’t coming to us with a plan to actually begin development?
I wish government had the self-respect and restraint to only bother the people with announcements of actual accomplishments.
2 thoughts on “Premier Marois to Stifle Opposition with MÃ©tro Extension Plan”
Hi Justin –
Thanks for posting.
The reasons, as far as I can figure them, are as follows:
1. The WI communities are all separate. Thus, they lack the ability to lobby together, and I would hazard to guess they pay less than the city of Montreal to the STM, which is in charge of public transit for much of the city.
2. The West Island has access to two high-capacity commuter rail lines as is. Eastern Montreal, by contrast, does not (or at least won’t until the Train de l’Est is completed). That train, incidentally, is supposed to pass far further to the North than the Blue Line extension.
3. The total West Island population is only about a quarter million people. The combined population of Saint-Michel, Saint-Leonard, Montreal-Nord and Anjou is easily more than that, but far more concentrated.
4. Extending the MÃ©tro to the West Island (like Fairview as an example) wouldn’t do much to ease congestion on Boul. St-Jean. It may even make it far worse. Further, I doubt Fairview’s management wants to see their parking spaces eaten up by commuters.
I definitely want better public transit options for the West Island, but we have to look at improving connectivity in smaller steps. For instance, extending the Orange Line through VSL to connect with the AMT’s Deux-Montagnes Line at Bois-Franc. This would help alleviate congestion on the most high-use AMT line, which would be good for commuters and potentially allow more people to use the DM line.
We could also look at extending hours of operation on the Vaudreil-Hudson line as well, and dedicating more reserved bus lanes throughout the West Island to quickly and efficiently move people from the residential subdivisions to major transit points, like commuter rail stations.
Personally, I’m of the opinion improving the stations and termini in the West Island would do a lot to encourage more West Island residents to take public transit. The biggest challenge we face in securing new riders is the often abysmal conditions of our public transit infrastructure. Have you been to the Dorval Terminus lately? It looks awful and there’s no services whatsoever. It’s pathetic.
Final note, before exploring a West Island MÃ©tro, we should look to see if the AMT could use the Hymus Spur – a rail line that goes nearly as far as Boul. St-Jean at highway 40.
What about the West Island? We have a huge population, the traffic coming in from the west island is terrible along Des Sources, St-Jean and St-Charles every single morning and all the calls going east into VSL and downtown. Why not add a line where actual masses of people could take advantage of it, rather than trying to increase ridership and property values on the least used line in the network?!